The making and unmaking of ignorance 1st edition by proctor, robert n. How climate science became a victim of the cold war naomi oreskes and erik m. The pdf of the article gives specific page numbers. This volume can be purchased in hardback or paperback. The making and unmaking of ignorance 2008, edited by robert n.
Pdf the study of ignorance, or agnotology, has many similarities with. The bartolo 2 star critique is one of complaint about form or language. Proctor and londa schiebinger, developed out of workshops at pennsylvania state university, the former in 2004. The logic of modern censorship peter galison 000 3. It would not be unreasonable, in fact, for scholars to look at documents like the.
Both anthologies grapple with ignorance as an important but hitherto overlooked and underdeveloped facet of. The study of culturallyinduced ignorance or doubt, particularly the publication of inaccurate or misleading scientific data. Agnotology simple english wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. A history of the knowledge and ignorance of harms from.
Agnotological examination of the critique of agnotology. Proctor and londa schiebinger stanford university press stanford, california. More generally, the term also highlights the increasingly common condition where more. Learning climate science by studying misinformation the. Animal production, aggag laws, and the social production of ignorance. The term agnotology was originally coined by proctor with the help of linguist iain boal, and the volume agnotology. Creator proctor, robert, 1954subjects ignorance theory of knowledge social aspects ignorance theory of knowledge social aspects congresses secrecy congresses. Science, commerce, and politics, coedited with claudia swan. The author delineates several kinds of ignorance in the paper, and they make for a good conceptual framework for understanding ignorance. The making and unmaking of ignorance book pdf agnotology. Agnotology is a branch of science which looks at the ways in which doubt or ignorance about certain subjects is created.
The making and unmaking of ignorance in format pdf, agnotology. In particular, agnotology has made evident the need for a. Please read the preface and chapter 1 of agnotology. Agnotology the making and unmaking of ignorance pdf is designed to take up to 300 pictures in just a few seconds, allowing you to pull out the perfect frame from a huge collection of shots. Taping the note makes the cursor appear in the box, so you can manually scroll. This paper outlines a framework for agnotology which is shaped by interdisciplinary studies of. Others have thought about ignorance in a more comprehensive way. Faced with such a question, i will start with this ideathat one of the affects of capitalism, that is, of thinking in terms of capitalism, is to generate. Agnotology formerly agnatology is the study of culturally induced ignorance or doubt, particularly the publication of inaccurate or misleading scientific data. The premise of agnotology the making and unmaking of ignorance pdf is very basic. The making and unmaking of ignorance click here to access this book. The making and unmaking of ignorance by robert n proctor and londa schiebinger eds stanford university press 2008 isbn 0804759014. How institutional ambiguity and deliberate ignorance shape sensitive spaces.
West indian abortifacients and the making of ignorance londa schiebincer 7. The united states current age of intellectual darkness has produced a society engaged in the widespread rejection of verifiable facts and scientific data resulting in fear, xenophobia, and a threat to democracy. Focusing on the mechanisms of ignorance production, the recent literature in agnotology has been a fruitful approach for understanding the social and epistemological consequences of commercialized science today. Proctor is such a person and he has coined a term for the cultural production and study of ignorance.
Proctor specializes in the history of 20th and 21stcentury scientific controversies, including the history of tobacco and. Proctor, a stanford university professor, and linguist iain boal. Proctor and londa schiebinger stanford university press. Sheila jasanoff, harvard university in the past years there have been few new fields of research as timely as agnotology. Published stanford, calif stanford university press, 2008. The cultural production of ignorance october 7th and 8th, 2005 9 am 5. Stel, n 2016 the agnotology of eviction in south lebanons palestinian gatherings. It would have a five star rating if not for a couple of people suffering from their own brand of ignorance. Agnotology the making and unmaking of ignorance pdf. It makes us ask what is at stake when we dont know things that are plainly before our eyes.
A missing term to describe the cultural production of ignorance and its study robert n. Robert proctors and londa schiebingers 2008 agnotology. Once youve read an article, you swipe the screen and the article disappears, with another article appearing. The making and unmaking of ignorance, coedited with. Our interest here, though, is less in remediation than in what nancy tuana has called the liberatory momentwhich brings us. In these two books, the project is overtly political in that the. This article examines how the current culture of ignorance has evolved in the postdigital age and contributes to studies on ignorance agnotology by examining the.
Agnotology is a term that has been used to describe the study of ignorance and its cultural production proctor in agnotology. The making and unmaking of ignorance a2 proctor, robert n. This paper outlines a framework for agnotology which is shaped by interdisciplinary studies of both ignorance and absence, and identifies properties such as chronicity, granularity, scale, intentionality, and ontology in relation to epistemology as useful for studying ignorance. Agnotology the making and unmaking of ignorance pdf is a reader for books, available in apps for most devices. Agnotology as a strategy in the debate over genetically engineered organisms david magnus. There have a l w a y s been lots of reasons to keep things secretfor love, for war, for business, for every conceivable human desire or enterprise. Publication date 2008 topics ignorance theory of knowledge. The essays assembled in agnotology show that ignorance is often more than just an absence of knowledge.
Ignorance has a history and a political geography, but there are also things people dont want you to know doubt is our product is the tobacco industry slogan. Journal of geography agnotology as a teaching tool. Agnotology, scientific consensus, and the teaching and. A crucial aspect of this examination, tuana suggests, is the rejection of ignorance theorized as a simple lack, omission, or gap 2004. Agnotology the making and unmaking of ignorance robert n proctor londa. A very good example of how this happens is the publication of scientific studies that rely on data that is inaccurate or misleading. For issues that are contentious in the societal realm, though largely not in the scientific realm, such as human evolution or the broad basics of humaninduced climate change, it has been. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Agnotology rescues ignorance from the nomansland of unexamined social phenomena. The making and unmaking of ignorance edited by robert n. Proctor has developed a new word agnotology which he defines as the study of culturally constructed ignorance. What keeps ignorance alive, or allows it to be used as a political instrument. I saw this book in my local public library and it caught my eye because im interested in ignorance.
102 199 814 1128 216 564 728 1590 135 1043 355 1599 1320 1204 1157 1087 1630 1583 1069 1179 1604 1632 323 93 1517 227 95 642 245 586 1463 24 589 257 844